Monday, December 22, 2008

JVC Everio GZ-MS100

Even as small as the MS100 is, it's very comfortable to use and does look and feel nice, despite being entirely plastic. The battery takes up most of the back there's just enough room for the record start or stop button to the right of it. On top are the zoom rocker and a snapshot button. You cannot take stills while shooting video, but instead need to flip a tiny switch on the left side of the body.

(Photos are 640x480 and are typical quality for SD camcorders good enough for the Web at small sizes, barely.) Above that switch sits a button to flip between play and record, and below it is one for changing out of Auto mode to Manual.

Then there is the ballyhooed one touch Upload button and its partner Direct DVD button. This one button YouTube upload, though, really just connects, transcodes, and uploads via the bundled Cyberlink software (Windows only).

It certainly doesn't relieve you of having to be in front of your computer to keep the process moving start to finish. This is not really any different than the MS100's competitors, except in that some of them have the software built into the camcorder so you don't have to worry about where the software's installed. Then there are the Laser Touch controls.

Down the left side of the flip out 2.7 inch LCD is a touch sensitive strip that sort of takes the place of a joystick or directional pad. However, those generally have five directions used for selecting things. The strip, while responsive and pretty it lights up a brilliant blue when stroked only handles scrolling up and down, or for adjusting focus, exposure, and shutter speed in Manual mode.

JVC Everio GZ-MG330

First and foremost, the whole of the MG300 series are very compact camcorders, measuring only 4.5 inches wide by 2.7 inches tall by 2.2 inches deep, and weighing about 12.7 ounces with battery. That's small enough to be of little consequence, even if you hold it for several hours. Unlike the touch screen, joystick, or jog dial controls used by other manufacturers, JVC has a unique Laser Touch control bar a clever blue light LED vertical touch sensitive strip at the left of the 2.7 in LCD screen, which lets you quickly skim through all the menu selections.

You make the actual selections with five small, recessed buttons at the bottom of the LCD. This arrangement is surprisingly functional.

Frequently needed items sit at the top level of the menus, including video quality, gain control (for low light shooting), aspect ratio (16:9 or 4:3), scene exposure modes, and backlight compensation.

One level deeper into the manual settings menu reveals exposure compensation, manual focus, white balance, shutter speed, and metering options. The camcorder offers a typical bundle of features for the money. It uses a 1/6 inch charge coupled device sensor with 680.000 pixel resolution pretty conventional for a standard definition camcorder along with a 35x zoom lens and 2.7 inch wide screen LCD monitor.

Sadly, but unsurprisingly, no viewfinder is present. It records MPEG-2 video in four quality modes with varying bit rates. Ultra Fine (8.5Mbps), Fine (5.5Mbps), Normal (4.2Mbps) and Economy (352x240 at 1.5Mbps). Though recording time increases as you decrease bit rate, quality also degrades, and Ultra Fine quality isn't so good that it can afford to decrease.

With the 30GB hard drive, the camcorder's recording times range from about 7 hours in Ultra Fine mode to just over 37 hours in Economy for the 60GB models, that doubles to 14 hours and 74 hours, respectively. You can also record video and stills to a Micro SD card. JVC includes a composite video or stereo RCA cable for TV playback, and bundles a CD of CyberLink software for transferring your video content from the camcorder to your Windows computer for further editing. You can also simply copy the files to your Mac or PC.

JVC Everio GZ-MG 335

First and foremost, the whole of the MG300 series are very compact camcorders, measuring only 4.5 inches wide by 2.7 inches tall by 2.2 inches deep, and weighing about 12.7 ounces with battery. That's small enough to be of little consequence, even if you hold it for several hours. Unlike the touch screen, joystick, or jog dial controls used by other manufacturers, JVC has a unique Laser Touch control bar a clever blue light LED vertical touch sensitive strip at the left of the 2.7 in LCD screen, which lets you quickly skim through all the menu selections.

You make the actual selections with five small, recessed buttons at the bottom of the LCD. This arrangement is surprisingly functional. Frequently needed items sit at the top level of the menus, including video quality, gain control (for low light shooting), aspect ratio (16:9 or 4:3), scene exposure modes, and backlight compensation.

One level deeper into the manual settings menu reveals exposure compensation, manual focus, white balance, shutter speed, and metering options. The camcorder offers a typical bundle of features for the money.

It uses a 1/6 inch charge coupled device sensor with 680.000 pixel resolution pretty conventional for a standard definition camcorder along with a 35x zoom lens and 2.7 inch wide screen LCD monitor.

Sadly, but unsurprisingly, no viewfinder is present. It records MPEG-2 video in four quality modes with varying bit rates. Ultra Fine (8.5Mbps), Fine (5.5Mbps), Normal (4.2Mbps) and Economy (352x240 at 1.5Mbps). Though recording time increases as you decrease bit rate, quality also degrades, and Ultra Fine quality isn't so good that it can afford to decrease.

With the 30GB hard drive, the camcorder's recording times range from about 7 hours in Ultra Fine mode to just over 37 hours in Economy for the 60GB models, that doubles to 14 hours and 74 hours, respectively. You can also record video and stills to a Micro SD card. JVC includes a composite video or stereo RCA cable for TV playback, and bundles a CD of CyberLink software for transferring your video content from the camcorder to your Windows computer for further editing. You can also simply copy the files to your Mac or PC.

JVC Everio GZ-MG 360

First and foremost, the whole of the MG300 series are very compact camcorders, measuring only 4.5 inches wide by 2.7 inches tall by 2.2 inches deep, and weighing about 12.7 ounces with battery. That's small enough to be of little consequence, even if you hold it for several hours. Unlike the touch screen, joystick, or jog dial controls used by other manufacturers, JVC has a unique Laser Touch control bar a clever blue light LED vertical touch sensitive strip at the left of the 2.7 in LCD screen, which lets you quickly skim through all the menu selections.

You make the actual selections with five small, recessed buttons at the bottom of the LCD. This arrangement is surprisingly functional.

Frequently needed items sit at the top level of the menus, including video quality, gain control (for low light shooting), aspect ratio (16:9 or 4:3), scene exposure modes, and backlight compensation.

One level deeper into the manual settings menu reveals exposure compensation, manual focus, white balance, shutter speed, and metering options.

The camcorder offers a typical bundle of features for the money. It uses a 1/6 inch charge coupled device sensor with 680.000 pixel resolution pretty conventional for a standard definition camcorder along with a 35x zoom lens and 2.7 inch wide screen LCD monitor. Sadly, but unsurprisingly, no viewfinder is present. It records MPEG-2 video in four quality modes with varying bit rates.

Ultra Fine (8.5Mbps), Fine (5.5Mbps), Normal (4.2Mbps) and Economy (352x240 at 1.5Mbps). Though recording time increases as you decrease bit rate, quality also degrades, and Ultra Fine quality isn't so good that it can afford to decrease. With the 30GB hard drive, the camcorder's recording times range from about 7 hours in Ultra Fine mode to just over 37 hours in Economy for the 60GB models, that doubles to 14 hours and 74 hours, respectively.

You can also record video and stills to a Micro SD card. JVC includes a composite video or stereo RCA cable for TV playback, and bundles a CD of CyberLink software for transferring your video content from the camcorder to your Windows computer for further editing. You can also simply copy the files to your Mac or PC.

Panasonic SDR-SW20

The SW20's major selling point is its sturdy, waterproof body. It's protected down to 5 feet underwater for a maximum of 30 minutes at a time, adhering to the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) 60529 IPX8 standard. It's also dust proof and resists damage if dropped from heights up to 4 feet (using MIL STD 810F method 516.5 for shock testing).

And for all its toughness, the SW20, which records MPEG-2 video at a maximum of 10Mbps to SD or SDHC cards, weighs only slightly more than 8 ounces and measures 1.3 inches wide by 2.5 inches high by 4.5 inches deep.

It's worth noting, too, that Panasonic warns that the water resistant packing degrades over time and recommends that a dealer replace the packing at least once every 18 months.

The SW20's horizontal camcorder design at least when compared with competitor Sanyo's pistol grip Xacti VPC-E1 allows for its 10x optical zoom.

However the zoom is not smooth, with video visibly jerking up and down as the internal lens extends and retracts (it's especially noticeable if the subject is still). Panasonic put a record or pause button both on the front right of the camcorder (handy when using an overhand grip shooting at a low angle) and at the natural thumb position at the back for an underhand grip. You'd better keep a good grip on the SW20, though, because the included hand strap while cleverly making use of the tripod threads in the bottom is far from secure. Not great for its active use purpose.

Panasonic HDC-SD9

The Panasonic HDC-SD9 seems to be quite an attractive buy for a flash based AVCHD camcorder. At 11.7 ounces with battery and SD card and only 3.6 inches long, it's certainly one of the smallest and lightest full size camcorders we've ever tested, and is pretty comfortable to shoot. The zoom switch feels responsive, and all the controls seem logically placed and fluid to operate.

Many of the buttons, especially the face detection and Pre-rec (for 3 second pre-recording) are a tad small, but that's to be expected on a device this size. As with other compact camcorders, only a few controls remain under your right thumb zoom, photo, capture, playback, power, and recording start or stop. All the rest of the controls sit in the LCD enclosure.

The joystick is in an especially odd place which requires some getting used to for instance, pressing the joystick towards you produces the same result as moving it to the right in a traditional orientation, while pressing it away will navigate to the left.

I was relatively comfortable with this design, but our Lab tech disliked it. However, Panasonic made a few irritating design choices, especially with regard to the battery.

To remove it, you have to open the LCD cover that's fine, as long as you don't use Quick Start mode, which turns the power on when you open the door. In that circumstance, when you open the LCD to remove the battery as you must to charge it, since you can't charge the battery in camera the camcorder naturally turns on, and removing the battery at that point leaves the electronic lens cover open.

Furthermore, to download the files to your computer you must plug in the AC adapter (a pretty common requirement), but since the connector is in the battery compartment you have to remove the battery to do so. Furthermore, Panasonic offers an optional Shooting Guide which prompts you with "Camera panning too fast," "Use Intelligent Contrast," "Use O.I.S.," and "Use Low Light Mode" messages.

Unfortunately, each of these messages takes up a huge chunk of the already too crowded 2.7 inch LCD, blocking your view of the scene entirely. In the case of contrast and panning, the messages seem to appear more frequently than not.

Panasonic AG-HSC1U

Panasonic's just beginning to make a push in AVCHD for professional applications. The company's P2 flash card format has been widely adopted by the professional community, however, the cards are expensive and too large to fit in more compact devices. The HSC1U represents Panasonic's first attempt to supply that market with a relatively inexpensive alternative it records 1080i HD video in AVCHD format onto cheap and widely available SD cards media.

For pros, switching to a new format can be a bit of a risk. You're not only committing to a camera, but also to an entire work flow, including editing, archiving, and distribution.

Fortunately, AVCHD has much better software support from professional editing applications than consumer applications however, Adobe Premiere Pro remains an unsupportive holdout.

The cylindrical AG-HSC1U is about 5.5 inches long and 2.5 inches in diameter, and weighs about a pound. With a hand strap on the right and a rubberized ridge along the top, the camera fits well in the right hand.

Unlike its more flamboyant consumer oriented cousin, the HSC1U has a low key matte gray finish. At the camera's front is a 43mm diameter Leica Dicomar 12x zoom lens, protected by nifty automatically retracting shutters you can't lose the lens cap to this camera. Next to the lens is a tiny flash, used for taking stills. Lacking a conventional viewfinder, the camera's rear is similarly straightforward in the center is the record button, surrounded by a mode dial.

To the side of this dial is a tiny joystick used to navigate menus, and below the dial are the menu and delete buttons. A hatch accessing the internal battery compartment is located at the bottom of the rear. Surprising in a camcorder this small, a generous 3 inch 16:9 560K pixel swing out LCD covers the entire left side of the camera.

Opening the LCD reveals an auto or manual focus switch, a Power LCD button to brighten the LCD for outdoor use, and a sliding door covering the slot which accommodates the SD card media. The camcorder includes one 4GB SDHC card. A small speaker adorns the camera's right side, which serves primarily as a hand grip. Atop are a microphone, a still photo button, and a zoom rocker.

The rocker switch is the least well executed of the controls so tiny that it is difficult to control with finesse. While there is much to admire in the simplified control layout of the HSC1U, it suffers from the same shortcomings of most compact video cameras namely, the controls are too small for easy manipulation by adult size hands. Panasonic's claim to have produced a professional level camera would gain much credibility if it could find a way to incorporate professional quality controls.